Disadvantages of Hard Pannier Luggage Systems For Motorcycles

Around the world, riding a motorcycle to get to work, for fun, or for long trips has been a popular activity for many decades. As a result, dedicated luggage systems for motorcycles are updated and sold around the world every so often. Motorcyclists frequently have to make the difficult decision of selecting the appropriate luggage setup for their vehicles. 

The two most common options that travelers take into account are the hard and soft pannier luggage systems. The motorcycle hard pannier luggage system is very popular among motorcycle travelers these days. However, hard panniers have certain drawbacks, even if they provide security and durability. 

In this article, we will talk about hard pannier baggage systems, compare them with their soft equivalents, and discuss the disadvantages of hard pannier systems.

What is a Hard Pannier Luggage System?

Like a hard case, a hard pannier system can hold multiple soft bags for storage. The hard cases are relatively shockproof due to their sturdy plastic or aluminum construction, protecting valuables from damage.

A hard pannier luggage system is made up of sturdy boxes that are attached to the sides of a motorcycle. These boxes are usually made of plastic or aluminum. These cases are meant to give riders on long trips a safe and weatherproof way to store their gear. People prefer hard panniers because they last longer and can keep what is inside safe from the weather.

The main attraction of the hard pannier system is how well-organized it is in comparison to other luggage systems. With their devices and gear neatly arranged, the rider can easily retrieve or store them, giving them peace of mind.

What is a Soft Pannier Luggage System?

In contrast, soft pannier luggage systems use flexible fabrics like canvas or nylon for storage bags. These bags are strapped to the motorcycle and are noted for their versatility and lightweight design. Soft panniers are frequently collapsible, making them convenient to store when not in use.

Differences Between Hard and Soft Pannier Luggage Systems

Let’s have a look at how hard pannier luggage systems are different from soft pannier ones.

Weight and Size

Hard panniers are typically bulkier and heavier than their soft counterparts. The increased weight can have an impact on the motorcycle’s handling, particularly during off-road adventures. Soft panniers, which are more lightweight and flexible, provide better maneuverability and are ideal for riders who value agility.

Durability

Hard panniers are known for their strong structure, which provides excellent protection for the cargo inside. However, they may break upon impact, which may require costly replacements. Soft panniers are less likely to be damaged in minor accidents, but they may not adequately protect fragile items inside.

Installation and Removal

Because of their hard mounting mechanisms, hard panniers take longer to install and remove than other types. Soft panniers are easier to attach and detach, allowing for quick and easy adjustments.

Versatility

Soft panniers are better suited to various shapes and sizes of objects. They also allow for overstuffing as necessary. Hard panniers have predetermined shapes, limiting their versatility and storage capacity.

Disadvantages of Hard Pannier Luggage Systems

There are certain disadvantages to hard panniers that you should think about before you decide to get them for your motorcycle luggage system. Here are some drawbacks of hard pannier luggage systems for motorcycles-

Cost

When compared to other types of luggage systems, motorcycle hard pannier systems are significantly more costly. Hard panniers are typically more expensive than soft ones, both in terms of initial purchase and replacement costs. Indeed, many motorcyclists and tourists simply do not have the financial means to purchase a high-quality hard pannier luggage system. 

Rigidity

The rigid nature of hard panniers can be a disadvantage during a fall or collision, as they may break or cause more damage to the motorcycle. Many seasoned motorcyclists believe that hard pannier luggage is dangerous for riders. Due to its heavy build and hard materials, it poses a greater risk of injury to riders in the event of a crash or when riding on off-road or unpaved terrain. Because of this, experienced riders frequently favor a soft luggage system in such circumstances.

Extra Added Weight

Compared to other motorcycle luggage systems, hard pannier luggage is the heaviest. As a result, when packed, it increases the overall dimensions and weight of a motorbike. As a result, it has a devastating effect on a motorcyclist’s stability, control, and comfort.

Weight Distribution

The main disadvantage of the hard pannier luggage system is that it often causes an inconvenient weight distribution on a motorcycle, which can make the rider seriously uncomfortable, especially on bumpy roads. The added weight of hard panniers can affect the motorcycle’s center of gravity, impacting handling and stability. So, to keep the weight of the motorcycle, even the rider might need to put other kinds of luggage in the front, like tank-top bags or roll-top bags. 

Limited Storage Capacity

While hard panniers may appear spacious, their fixed shapes can limit the types of items that can be stored, especially larger or irregularly shaped items.

Requires Large Bikes 

A hard pannier system requires a motorcycle that is relatively heavier and has a larger capacity, and it is not an option that can be used on any kind of motorcycle. Moreover, specific brackets and metal hangers are needed for each bike. Therefore, hard pannier luggage is not compatible with dirt bikes, scooters, or small commuter bikes. Only larger capacity and travel motorcycles, such as larger ADV or dual-sport motorcycles, can carry these types of luggage.

Noise 

Compared to a soft luggage system, a hard pannier system makes a louder noise. Metal, fiber, or polycarbonate are some of the hard materials that are used to make hard panniers. Braces and brackets are also made of metal. So, it can make noises on rough surfaces like gravel or paved roads, which can make it annoying at times.

Conclusion

While the hard pannier luggage systems for motorcycles feature numerous benefits, they also come with certain disadvantages that you should keep in mind while getting one for your bike. Weigh in all the benefits and drawbacks of hard pannier luggage systems and see if they work for you or not. Make sure to properly compare the benefits of both soft and hard pannier systems before you finally settle on one to get for your bike.